Computer programmer Chloe Malcolm doesn't know how she let her best friend talk her into attending her ten-year high school reunion. But when Dylan Echols – her former crush turned major league baseball player – mistakes her for a popular cheerleader, she decides to make the most of the Cinderella moment. Dylan can't believe it when the gorgeous woman he just kissed runs away. He's even more stunned to discover she's not the person he thought she was… Chloe knows she can't deceive the sexy sports star forever. But once she tells Dylan the truth, will she turn back into her tongue-tied former self? Or will he love her for who she is and give her the happily-ever-after she's always dreamed of?